ibex

CRO Testing Roadmap

April 2026

Overview

Cart trust friction is breaking checkout sessions on mobile at the highest-intent moment in the funnel, while both paid channels are making promises the landing page doesn't keep. These aren't edge cases: they're documented, and they're happening right now on the exact pages Ibex is paying to send customers to.

Slot 1 A/B Test

Cart: Carbon Offset

Page: Cart / ibex.com/cart

An EcoCart carbon offset charge auto-adds to every mobile cart as the first line item, displayed above the customer's own product with its own price, quantity controls, and a third-party logo. It is non-refundable and reloads after deletion. A documented customer returned their entire order over this in February 2026 and stated they will not shop at Ibex again.

* Concept illustration only. Final design will differ.
Slot 2 A/B Test

Sale Page Hero

Page: Sale Collection / ibex.com/collections/sale

Two of three active Meta ads drive to the sale page with urgency copy about final colorways and retiring styles. The current sale page hero is a generic road trip landscape with only "SALE" text: no urgency language, no product specificity. The emotional momentum from the ad does not carry through to the landing page.

* Concept illustration only. Final design will differ.
Slot 3 A/B Test

Announcement Bar: New Visitor Offer

Page: Sitewide / all pages (targeting new visitors from Google)

Google search ads actively promote a $20 off first order code to new visitors, but the announcement bar shows only free shipping info with no mention of the discount. First-time visitors from Google arrive expecting the offer and see no above-fold confirmation of it. A popup appears to carry this offer, but its timing and targeting are unknown.

* Concept illustration only. Final design will differ.
Data Sources
Meta Ads Google Ads Reviews & UGC Page Speed / Core Web Vitals Site Screenshots
Meta Ads
  • All 3 active ads started March 26, 2026. Two drive to the sale page with identical urgency copy: "Final colorways, retiring styles, and prices that reflect neither."
  • Ad #3 CTA specifically says "Shop Paradox Last Chance Colors" but lands on the general sale collection. No Paradox-specific section or filter on arrival.
  • The sale ads contain no product-benefit messaging. Merino quality, odor resistance, and performance attributes are absent. The paid message is entirely markdown-led.
Google Ads
  • "$20 off Your First Order - Code TRYIBEX20" appears as a promotion extension across multiple active search campaigns, but is not visible anywhere in the announcement bar or above the fold on-site.
  • Free shipping threshold is inconsistent: Google search ads state "$99+." The announcement bar on the sale page and PDP shows "$149+." Two different promises running simultaneously.
  • Google and Meta are running entirely different brand stories at the same time. Google is benefit-led (odor-resistant, UPF 50+, thermoregulating). Meta is urgency and markdown-led. New visitors see one story in the ad and a different one on the site.
Reviews & UGC
  • Men's Natural Boxer Brief: 109 on-site reviews, 4.5 stars. Consistent praise for comfort, breathability, and moisture management. "Most comfortable underwear I have ever worn" is a representative sentiment.
  • Recurring waistband complaint across 5+ reviews from 2021 to 2025: seam separation, elastic thinness, and fraying on the first or third wear. On a $55 product, this is the primary visible objection for prospective buyers.
  • Trustpilot shows 2.6/5 stars from 4 reviews. Three of four are 1-star, all centered on customer service accessibility: no phone support, no chat response, delayed refunds.
  • A verified February 2026 cart review documents a full order return after the EcoCart charge reloaded on cart edit and was missed. The reviewer stated they will not shop at Ibex again.
Page Speed / Core Web Vitals
  • Both paid traffic landing pages score 43-44 on mobile performance (Lighthouse, Slow 4G). Neither page is close to the 90+ threshold for Good performance.
  • The Boxer Brief PDP has an LCP of 19.2s. Meta Ad #2 sends paid mobile traffic directly to this page. Most visitors on Slow 4G may never see the main content load.
  • The sale collection page LCP is 13.6s. Two of three active Meta ads land here.
  • Top diagnostics on both pages: render-blocking requests (2,140ms savings potential), oversized images (2,024 KiB on homepage, 1,445 KiB on PDP), and 445 KiB of unused JavaScript on the homepage.
Site Screenshots
  • Cart (mobile): EcoCart appears as the first item in the cart, above the customer's actual product, with its own product tile, green third-party logo, price, description ("OFFSETS 116.16 LBS OF CARBON"), and quantity controls. It is visually indistinguishable from a product.
  • Sale page hero: Full-bleed road trip landscape with "SALE" overlaid. No urgency copy, no colorway references, no product in the image.
  • Homepage announcement bar: "Don't Miss Out: Last Chance Gear. Free shipping on orders over $149, US only." No TRYIBEX20 offer visible. A popup carrying this offer may exist, but its timing and targeting are undocumented.
  • Boxer Brief PDP: 109 reviews and 4.5 stars are visible near the price. M and L sizes are sold out. The "Field Notes" and "The Clip" feature accordions are collapsed on arrival, keeping key product details out of view.
Cross-Source Themes
Cart trust destruction
The EcoCart charge auto-adds as a non-refundable first item on mobile. It reloads after deletion. A documented customer returned their entire order over this. The cart screenshot confirms exactly what that customer described. (Sources: Cart screenshot, Reviews)
Meta message mismatch
Two of three active Meta ads build urgency around "final colorways, retiring styles." The sale page hero is a generic landscape with "SALE" text. The landing page does not follow through on the ad's emotional setup. (Sources: Meta Ads, Sale page screenshot)
Google message mismatch
Search ads promise $20 off a first order. The announcement bar makes no mention of this. New visitors arrive expecting confirmation and see none above the fold. The free shipping threshold also differs between the ad and the bar. (Sources: Google Ads, Site screenshots)
Mobile speed
Both paid traffic destinations score 43-44 on mobile. The Boxer Brief PDP LCP is 19.2 seconds. Meta is sending paid mobile traffic to a page that takes nearly 20 seconds to load its main content. (Source: Page Speed)

[ READY TO GROW? ]

Let's build your growth roadmap together.

Book a free 30-minute strategy call. No pitch, just a plan.

[ WHAT OUR CLIENTS SAY ]

At Performance Golf we have worked with dozens of agencies. We are a nine figure brand and growing and our agency experiences, let's just say they haven't been that great, but Convertibles has completely flipped that on its head.
Donnie French

Donnie French

Performance Golf - Offer Architect

Have thoroughly enjoyed working with the team. The process has been smooth sailing, the weekly updates are excellent and we have seen month on month growth in both conversion rate and sales since beginning to work together. Further, the team are also very happy to help if there are any little bugs etc and go above and beyond to deliver a great experience for our brand and our customers!
Joshua Robinson

Joshua Robinson

Founder - Garden Street Gin Club

We needed a very high conversion landing page for mostly cold, some semi warm traffic coming primarily off of social. I had heard about Convertibles, decided to give them a try. They knocked it out of the park. There is so much strategy they pour into every step of the process. I learned a ton as we went. They made it fun, easy and the site is performing way better than I was expecting or hoping. So thank you guys. Can't wait for the next one.
Nick Lange

Nick Lange

@nick.discovers

You guys are terrific. We love working with you. We've worked with agencies in the past and we were just a number. You've helped us tremendously with the growth of our company. Communication is fantastic, and we know you care about us and you put your heart and soul into it, so thank you so much. Highly, highly recommend.
Justin Katz

Justin Katz

CMO Mika & Sammy's Gourmet Dog Treats