Color Swatches on Product Cards: 1,200 More Product Page Visits, Zero More Add to Carts

Color swatches More clicks, same add to carts

[ FREE CRO TEARDOWN ]

Find the 3 biggest revenue leaks on your store.

Every day a conversion leak goes unfixed, you're paying for traffic that doesn't buy. Get a 5-minute Loom through your PDP, cart, and checkout, with mockups of the fixes. No pitch.

Get My Teardown
or
Book a Call

Color swatches on product cards got used. Rating scores got seen. A "Find Your Fit" row got tapped. About 1,200 more shoppers reached product pages. And add to carts did not move: 4,913 vs 4,914. After 39 days, this test ended with no winner.

This is the kind of result most agencies do not publish. We think it is one of the more useful ones, because it shows the gap between "shoppers engaged with it" and "shoppers bought more because of it".

The Bet: Make Browsing Easier

The brand sells handbags and accessories, mostly in many colors per style. On the collection pages, colors were hidden behind a hover, and the product cards showed stars without the score. Our bet was simple: if shoppers can see every color, see the rating and jump straight to the right type of bag, more of them will find one they want.

One variation against control, on every collection page, desktop and mobile:

  1. Always-visible color swatches. Image tiles for each color right on the product card, with a "+X" counter for styles with many colors, instead of a hover-only strip
  2. Rating score on the card. "4.9 (142)" next to the stars, moved up under the product title
  3. A "Find Your Fit" row. Six use-case tiles (Everyday, Hands-Free, Work, Going Out, Travel, Mini) inserted after the second row of products on bag collections

The Engagement Numbers Looked Like a Win

What shoppers did Result
Collection visitors who tapped a color swatch 15%
People who saw Find Your Fit and tapped a tile About 1 in 5
Extra shoppers reaching product pages About 1,200 more than control

If we had stopped at engagement, we would have called it a winner. Shoppers clearly liked the new features.

The Revenue Numbers Did Not Follow

Collection page visitors, 39 days Variation Control
Add to carts 4,913 4,914
Orders 839 848
Revenue per visitor vs control -3.1% -

How we measured it: every number covers people who viewed a collection page, the only visitors who could see the change. The variation and control were close on revenue, so we ended the test with no winner and removed the code.

Why More Product Page Visits Did Not Mean More Sales

Our read: the features helped people browse, but finding a bag was not what stopped them from buying.

  • Shoppers who were going to buy found their bag anyway. The same number added to cart in both versions. The new features changed the route, not the destination
  • Extra product page visits were mostly extra browsing. Visible colors invite people to open more styles to compare. That is more clicks per shopper, not more shoppers deciding
  • The real blocker sits later. If add to carts are flat while product page visits rise, the next test belongs on the product page or in the cart, not on the grid

What We Would Do Differently

  1. Judge collection page tests on add to cart and revenue per visitor, never on clicks to product pages alone
  2. Before building grid features, check where shoppers actually drop off. Here, the funnel said the grid was doing its job
  3. Test one feature at a time when engagement is the question. With three changes in one variation, we know the bundle did not move revenue, but not which part helped or hurt
  4. Keep the learning, not the code. The test was removed cleanly and the next tests moved down the funnel

For collection page changes that did move revenue, see our Shopify collection page optimization guide. For the product page side, see the lifestyle image first gallery test.

Swatch and Product Card Test Questions

Do color swatches on collection pages increase conversions?

Not in this test. Always-visible color swatches got a tap from 15% of collection visitors and, with ratings and a use-case row, sent about 1,200 more shoppers to product pages. Add to carts stayed flat (4,913 vs 4,914) and revenue per visitor was 3.1% lower, so the test ended with no winner.

Should I show the rating score on product cards?

We cannot say from this test alone. The rating score ran in one bundle with swatches and use-case tiles, and the bundle as a whole did not change how many shoppers added to cart.

Why would more product page views not increase sales?

Because extra views can be extra browsing. If the people who were going to buy find their product either way, better navigation changes the route, not the result.

How long did the test run?

39 days, with 839 orders for the variation and 848 for control among collection page visitors.

Why publish a test with no winner?

Because it saves other brands from shipping the same "obvious" improvement. Engagement went up and revenue did not. That is worth knowing before you build.

Want this kind of testing on your store? See how our Shopify CRO agency plans, builds and reads tests like this one.

[ SAY HI AND LET'S MAKE YOU SOME MONEY ]