Spikeball December Roadmap
Next concepts · Convertibles
After the sale
November's tests are live or in build. These five come next: tests and changes on pages your buyers already use, each built Problem, Solution, Impact.
Three big swings, two gaps
At a glance
Five concepts, timed for December
Tap a card to jump to it. Three A/B tests run and read before testing pauses in January, the Amazon test first. Two ship as changes in January. 01-03 are big swings; 04-05 close gaps where buyers drop today.
TITAN: buy here or on Amazon
A/B test · Margin02From 1 DecParts for life: a reason to buy direct
A/B test · Buy direct03JanuaryGroup packs on the set pages
Implementation · AOV041 - 21 DecSpikepong: pick 1, 2 or 3 on the product page
A/B test · AOV05Fix now · JanShipping under $75: one honest, low price
Fix now + January changeWhere November stands
Every November concept is live, in build or queued
The site still can't win on price. So the next concepts win on "more" or on a reason to buy here.
Live since 5 Nov. Earliest read 19 Nov.
Live since 12 Nov on TITAN, Pro, 1-Ball and Weekender. TITAN comes out about 20 Nov for the Amazon test.
In build. Due 18 Nov.
In build. Target 18 Nov.
Waiting on the Aftersell install. Needs Chris.
Approved 5 Nov. Queued behind the tests above.
- No discount deeper than Amazon's on the same dates. Every concept wins on "more" or on a reason to buy here.
- One test per part of the site at a time. The Amazon test takes the TITAN buy box first, because December volume can't wait.
- A/B testing pauses from January. Every test here runs and reads in December; the rest ship as changes in January.
- US only. Product data stays in NetSuite; new content goes in sections Shopify keeps.
TITAN: buy here or on Amazon
The TITAN product page. Kyle's split: half keep our checkout, half send "Buy" to Amazon.
Problem
Every TITAN sold on spikeball.com may earn less than the same sale on Amazon. Nobody has measured it.
- Amazon ships more cheaply, and margins on the site are "not great" (Chris, 26 Oct).
- TITAN is a third of site revenue: $33,598 in 60 days to 29 Oct, with the best margin.
- Chris green-lit the test on 6 Nov for the high-volume weeks: "Testing in Jan or Feb will be tough." He needs the answer to decide how much TITAN stock to send to Amazon.
Solution
Same TITAN page, one change: the buy button goes to Amazon for half of visitors.
- Today's TITAN page stays the control. For half of visitors, Intelligems swaps the buy button for Kyle's Amazon link, same price (agreed 16 Nov).
- The bundle selector hides in the Amazon variation, so the only choice is the Amazon button.
- Live about 20 Nov to 11 Dec, through both sale weeks. TITAN comes out of SB02 to free the buy box. US only, same on phones and computers.
Impact
A clear answer to which channel earns more per TITAN visitor.
- Judged on profit per visitor: site margin after shipping vs Amazon payout + the 10% Brand Referral Bonus.
- If Amazon wins, TITAN ad traffic can go there for good. That answers Chris's 6 Nov stock question.
We need: Kyle: the Amazon Attribution report weekly, and should the TITAN bundle selector hide in the Amazon variation? Matt: margin after shipping per TITAN order. Us: TITAN out of SB02, and TITAN ad traffic kept out of this test while the TITAN landing page test runs.
Example figures: Button copy and the bonus line are examples. The button uses the Amazon Attribution link Kyle shared.
Concept illustration only. Final design will differ.
Parts for life: a reason to buy direct
The 3-Ball page from 1 Dec. Pro and Weekender join when SB02 reads there. TITAN is busy with 01. Plus a "Find your part" step on the spare parts page.
Problem
The site has no reason to buy here instead of Amazon, and broken parts are pulling the rating down.
- Broken parts are 35% of 1-2 star reviews on spikeball.com. On Amazon, "broke" is 26% of negatives.
- Buyers who knew about free parts stayed happy after a break. Others never knew: "no mention of it in the box".
- The site rating fell from 4.84 before 2024 to 3.85 since (346 reviews).
- Owners can't find their part: searches are mostly parts, and the spare parts page had 448 views from 68 people in 30 days.
Solution
Turn the parts promise into a reason to buy direct, and make parts easy to find.
- Right under Add to cart: "Bought here? Broken part? We send a new one. For life."
- "Find your part": pick your set, pick the part, request it. Replaces the form that doesn't submit.
- Control: today's set pages. Variation: the promise line and link. Runs 1-31 Dec, so it reads before the January pause.
Impact
More set buyers choose spikeball.com over Amazon, and fewer breaks turn into 1-star reviews.
- Judged on revenue per visitor on the set pages.
- Second read: parts requests and the rating of new reviews, against today's 3.85.
We need: Chris: what the parts policy is today, and whether we can promise "for life, bought on spikeball.com". Matt: parts stock and NetSuite impact. We need the policy by 24 Nov to start 1 Dec. If it comes later, this ships as a January change without a test.
Example figures: The promise wording follows your policy answer. "For life" is the swing; "5 years" is the safe version.
Concept illustration only. Final design will differ.
Group packs on the set pages
The TITAN and 3-Ball product pages, right under the price. No new page.
Problem
Group buyers already buy several sets, but the set pages only sell one at a time.
- About 1 in 8 paying TITAN orders already have 2 to 5 sets, often with 10 or 20-ball packs.
- Reviews mention church, youth groups or clubs 301 times. PE teachers buy 6 to 9 sets at a time.
- Big groups (10+ sets) have no way to reach your sales team from the page.
Solution
A "Buying for a group?" choice on the TITAN and 3-Ball pages.
- Three choices: just me, a ready group pack, or "10+ sets? Get a quote".
- Youth group pack (2 TITANs + 20 balls) and Class pack (4 sets + balls + bags). Full price, ship free.
- Built in December, switched on for everyone in January. No A/B test: the set pages are busy with 01 and 02 in December.
Impact
Bigger group orders in one tap, and big groups reach your sales team.
- Read on sets per order and group pack sales, against the same weeks last year.
- Quote requests tracked on their own. Answers your 13 Nov youth group question without a new page.
We need: Sales team (Wendy, Jess): who answers 10+ quotes. Matt: pack SKUs and NetSuite impact. Build in December, live early January, when groups plan spring.
Example figures: Pack contents and prices are examples. We size them from real multi-set orders before build.
Concept illustration only. Final design will differ.
Spikepong: pick 1, 2 or 3 on the product page
The Spikepong product page buy box. The same offer as the approved Spikepong page, tested where the traffic already lands.
Problem
Spikepong is the holiday best-seller, but almost everyone buys one and pays shipping.
- 17-30 Nov 2025: 4,614 sold, $163.9k, about one per order ($47 per order).
- 17,421 holiday visits landed on the Spikepong product page, against 2,659 on the Spikepong landing page.
- 92% of buyers are women, mostly buying gifts. One Spikepong pays shipping, though the page says "Complimentary shipping".
- Last 30 days: 94 add to carts, 20 bought.
Solution
Replace the quantity box with 1, 2 or 3 sets. 2 or more ship free.
- 2 sets ("most gifted") picked by default.
- Full price per set, so Amazon parity holds. The only extra is free shipping from 2.
- Test 50/50 against today's page, US only, 1-21 Dec: the gift weeks, up to the Christmas shipping cutoff.
Impact
More buyers take two: one to keep, one to give.
- If 1 in 10 of last year's 3,978 sale-week orders had added a second set: about $14k more (an assumption, not a forecast).
- Judged on revenue per visitor and sets per order. If it wins, we don't need the separate Spikepong page.
We need: Hadas and Kyle: does free shipping from 2 count against Amazon parity? Finance (Arjuna): sign-off on free shipping for 2+ Spikepongs. Both by 24 Nov to start 1 Dec.
Example figures: Prices are today's $34.99 per set. "Most gifted" wording is a draft.
Concept illustration only. Final design will differ.
Shipping under $75: one honest, low price
Every product page, the cart and checkout. Most of the change is the shipping rate, not the page.
Problem
Most orders are small, and they meet a shipping charge the page said wasn't there.
- 57% of US orders are under $50 (median $34.99, 60 days to 29 Oct). They all pay shipping.
- Spikepong and Traveler pages say "Complimentary shipping & returns". Then checkout adds shipping.
- Under-$75 items stall after the cart: Spikepong 20 bought from 86 phone carts, Traveler 2 from 34 (30 days).
- 16 reviews complain, like "$10 to ship" a "$7" part. Amazon ships these free with Prime.
Solution
Remove the false line this week. Switch to one flat, low rate under $75 in January.
- This week, no test: remove "Complimentary shipping" from pages under $75.
- January: one flat low rate under $75 (e.g. $4.95), shown on the page and in the cart. A change, not a test: December's slot goes to Spikepong (04), which also changes Spikepong shipping.
- Free over $75 stays, so Taikun's ads stay true.
Impact
More of the 57% small orders finish checkout instead of leaving for Amazon.
- Read on orders under $75 and shipping income, against the same weeks last year.
- If it costs more than it brings, we switch back. It can run as a proper test when A/B testing restarts.
We need: Matt: what a small parcel costs us to ship. Finance (Arjuna): sign-off on the rate before January. Taikun: a heads-up, though the $75 line in ads doesn't change.
Example figures: $4.95 and delivery days are examples. The rate comes from Matt's shipping cost.
Concept illustration only. Final design will differ.
Found along the way
Fixes, no test needed
Clear breaks we found in the data. We fix them directly.
In 30 days, SMS sent 228 visits and none became an order. 134 went to the Traveler launch page, which shows no price and had 0 add to carts. We'll add the price and Add to cart, and ask Structured to point holiday sends at the gift guide or Spikepong.
Shown on items under $75 that pay shipping. Remove it now (see 05).
About 14,700 visits in 12 months, about 65 add to carts. We'll add a "Get your own set" link to the sets, and fix the video block, which reads "Become a reseller overview".
Queued behind live tests
Follow-ups
Smaller ideas that wait for a live test to read first.
Set buyers get a one-tap Traveler offer "for the trip", full price. Waits for SB04; if SB04 can't read in December, it moves to when testing restarts.
"Taking it on vacation? Add a Traveler." on TITAN and 3-Ball pages. Spring, when testing restarts and Traveler is in season.
"Dogs love popping these." ball line in the cart, with Hunter's puppy photo. After the gear ladder.
January: "The game for when it's too cold outside." A copy change, no test, after the Spikepong 1/2/3 test reads.
To start
What we need from you
Each answer unlocks a concept above.
Your question, 13 Nov
The pages you asked about
Two are in build. The rest are folded into tests on existing pages, or need rights first.
Prepared from Shopify orders, Google Analytics, Yotpo reviews, your Amazon review and copy guide docs, the Marketing Calendar, Meta (DataDruid) and Slack, to 17 Nov 2026 · Convertibles