How to Set a Free Shipping Threshold: What Our A/B Tests Showed

Free Shipping Threshold How to set it

[ FREE CRO TEARDOWN ]

Find the 3 biggest revenue leaks on your store.

Every day a conversion leak goes unfixed, you're paying for traffic that doesn't buy. Get a 5-minute Loom through your PDP, cart, and checkout, with mockups of the fixes. No pitch.

Get My Teardown
or
Book a Call

A good free shipping threshold sits a small stretch above what most shoppers already spend. Start from your typical order value and what shipping really costs you, pick a threshold slightly above most orders, then test it against one lower and one higher option. In one of our tests, the middle threshold won with +6.5% profit per visitor, and the highest threshold did worse than the original.

Most brands pick theirs by gut feel or by copying a competitor. That is a guess. The right number depends on your orders, your margins and your shipping costs, and the only way to know is to test it.

This guide walks through a simple way to set it, what our own A/B tests showed, and how to set it up on Shopify.

  • Who this is for: Shopify brands that offer free shipping over a set amount, or are thinking about it
  • What you will learn: a 5-step method, the math, and two real test results
  • What you need: your order data from the Shopify admin and your average shipping cost per order

What Is a Free Shipping Threshold?

A free shipping threshold is the order amount where shipping becomes free. "Free shipping on orders over $75" means $75 is the threshold. Below it, the shopper pays for shipping. Above it, you do.

The threshold moves three things at once:

  • Conversion rate. A lower threshold means less friction, so more people buy
  • Average order value (AOV). A higher threshold pushes people to add more to qualify
  • Shipping cost. A lower threshold means you pay for shipping on more orders

That is why you cannot judge a threshold on conversion rate alone. You need one number that holds all three. We use profit per visitor: what you earn after product and shipping costs, divided by the number of visitors.

How to Set a Free Shipping Threshold in 5 Steps

1. Find your typical order value

Pull your AOV from the Shopify admin for the last 90 days. Then look at the spread, not just the average. If most orders land between $45 and $65, that range matters more than one average number pulled up by a few big orders.

2. Know what shipping really costs you

Take your average shipping cost per order, including packaging. If you ship heavy or bulky products, check it by product type. This is the cost you take on for every order over the threshold.

3. Know your margin

Free shipping is paid out of your margin. A brand with a 70% gross margin can give away more shipping than a brand at 35%. If one free shipping order wipes out most of the profit on a small basket, your threshold is too low.

4. Pick a starting point a small stretch above most orders

The threshold should be reachable with one more item, not three. If your typical order is $55 and your cheapest add-on is $12, a threshold around $65 is a one-item stretch. A threshold of $90 asks for a stretch most shoppers will not make.

5. Test it against one lower and one higher option

Run your starting threshold next to one option below it and one above it. Judge them on profit per visitor. This is the step most brands skip, and it is the step that tells you where profit actually peaks.

Here is a simple example plan for a store with a typical order around $55 and a $12 add-on:

Version Example threshold What it tells you
Control $50 Where you are today
Variation 1 $65 Does a small stretch lift order value without losing buyers?
Variation 2 $80 Where does the stretch get too big?

You want one option you think is too generous and one you think is too hard. If the winner sits at an edge, you have not found the peak yet, so test again one step further out.

The Math Behind a Free Shipping Threshold

Every threshold is a trade. Here is what usually happens as you move it up:

Threshold Conversion rate Order value Shipping you pay for Typical result
Too low High Flat, most orders qualify already On almost every order Money left on the table
Small stretch About the same Up, some shoppers add one item On fewer orders Profit peaks here
Too high Down Up for the few who stretch On the fewest orders Lost buyers cost more than you save

A quick check before you test: if you raise the threshold, how many orders sit just under the new number? Those are the shoppers you are asking to stretch. If that group is a big share of your orders, the test is worth running. If almost no orders sit near it, the change will do little either way.

What Our Free Shipping Threshold Test Showed

We tested the free shipping threshold for an 8-figure adult wellness brand. The control kept their existing threshold. Variation 1 raised it by about 20%. Variation 2 raised it by about 50%. The test ran sitewide and we judged it on profit per visitor.

Version Threshold Profit per visitor vs control
Control Existing threshold Baseline
Variation 1 (winner) About 20% higher +6.5%
Variation 2 About 50% higher About 3% lower

The middle threshold won. Not the lowest, not the highest.

  • The original was too generous. Most orders already qualified, so the brand paid for shipping on nearly every order without getting anything extra back
  • The middle one was a small stretch. Some shoppers added an item to qualify, others paid for shipping. Either way, profit per visitor went up
  • The highest one pushed too hard. The gap from a normal order to free shipping got too big. Some shoppers neither stretched nor paid. They left

The lesson: a higher threshold is not always more profit. There is a point where the buyers you lose cost more than the shipping you save. You only find that point by testing both sides of it. The full write-up is in our free shipping threshold case study.

Show the Threshold: A Free Shipping Progress Bar in the Cart

A threshold only works if shoppers know about it. If the message lives in a banner they scrolled past, it does nothing at the moment they decide to check out or add one more item. That moment is the cart.

For a DTC food brand, we tested a free shipping progress bar in the cart drawer (the cart that slides in from the side). Free shipping and pack discounts kicked in at set amounts, but the drawer showed none of it.

Version What the cart drawer showed
Control No free shipping message
Variation 1 A free shipping progress bar: "You're $X away from FREE shipping"
Variation 2 (shipped) The same bar, plus a one-click button to upgrade to the next pack size

Variation 2 finished with +24% revenue per visitor vs control, at 88% probability to beat it. A version with the progress bar led control at every read we made. It is now live on the store.

How we measured it: these numbers count only shoppers who opened the cart drawer, not every visitor to the store. Across all visitors the lift would be smaller. It was also a small test, about 100 orders per version, so treat +24% as a direction, not a precise number. Details are in the free shipping progress bar case study.

Three things to copy from that build:

  • Show the exact gap ("$12 away"), not a vague "add more for free shipping"
  • Give one clear next step, like a button that adds the item for the shopper
  • Check the real shipping rules in the Shopify admin before you build the bar, then check again before it goes live

One warning. Free shipping is not always the strongest message. For a brand with a free gift program, we tested a cart drawer that led with free shipping against one that led with free gift progress. The free gift message won, and the free shipping lead did not beat it. If your best offer is something else, lead with that. See the cart drawer free gift case study.

How to Set a Free Shipping Threshold on Shopify

Shopify handles this with a shipping rate that has a minimum order price.

  1. In the Shopify admin, go to Settings, then Shipping and delivery
  2. Open the shipping profile and the zone you want, like your home country
  3. Add a rate, name it "Free shipping" and set the price to $0
  4. Add a condition based on order price and set the minimum to your threshold
  5. Keep a paid rate for orders below the threshold, so shoppers under it still see a clear price

To test thresholds against each other, you need an A/B testing app that can split shipping rates between visitors. We run these tests in Intelligems. Changing the number for everyone and comparing this month to last month is not a test, because seasons, ads and sales all move at the same time.

Free Shipping Threshold Mistakes to Avoid

  • Copying a competitor. Their orders, margins and shipping costs are not yours
  • Judging on conversion rate only. A lower threshold almost always wins on conversion and can still lose on profit
  • Setting it far above most orders. A big gap does not push shoppers to spend more. It pushes some to leave
  • Hiding it. If the cart does not show how close the shopper is, the threshold cannot do its job
  • Setting it once and forgetting it. Prices, products and shipping costs change. Retest when they do

About 70% of carts are abandoned (from our ecommerce conversion rate benchmarks). The threshold is one of the few levers that can lower that number and raise order value at the same time.

Free Shipping Threshold Questions

What is a good free shipping threshold?

One that sits a small stretch above what most shoppers already spend, usually reachable with one more item. In our test, raising the threshold by about 20% won with +6.5% profit per visitor, while raising it by about 50% did worse than the original.

Should the free shipping threshold be higher than my AOV?

Usually slightly higher, so some shoppers add an item to qualify. If it sits below your AOV, most orders already qualify and you pay for shipping without getting a bigger basket back. If it sits far above, some shoppers leave instead of stretching.

How do I test a free shipping threshold?

Run your current threshold against one lower and one higher option at the same time, with an A/B testing app that splits shipping rates between visitors. Judge the result on profit per visitor, not conversion rate alone.

Does a free shipping progress bar increase sales?

In our cart drawer test it did. A version with a free shipping progress bar and a one-click pack upgrade lifted revenue per visitor by 24% for shoppers who opened the cart, at 88% probability to beat control.

Is free shipping on all orders better than a threshold?

Only if your margins can carry it and your orders are already large. Free shipping on everything removes the push to add one more item. For most brands, a tested threshold earns more profit.

Want to know where your free shipping threshold should sit? See how our Shopify CRO agency plans, builds and reads tests like these.

[ SAY HI AND LET'S MAKE YOU SOME MONEY ]